SCARF: Auto-Segmentation Clinical Acceptability & Reproducibility Framework for Benchmarking Essential Radiation Therapy Targets in Head and Neck Cancer

Abstract

Background and Purpose: Auto-segmentation of organs at risk (OAR) in cancer patients is essential for enhancing radiotherapy planning efficacy and reducing inter-observer variability. Deep learning auto-segmentation models have shown promise, but their lack of transparency and reproducibility hinders their generalizability and clinical acceptability, limiting their use in clinical settings. Materials and Methods: This study introduces SCARF (auto-Segmentation Clinical Acceptability & Reproducibility Framework), a comprehensive six-stage reproducible framework designed to benchmark open-source convolutional neural networks for auto-segmentation of 19 essential OARs in head and neck cancer (HNC). Results: SCARF offers an easily implementable framework for designing and reproducibly benchmarking auto-segmentation tools, along with thorough expert assessment capabilities. Expert assessment labelled 16/19 AI-generated OAR categories as acceptable with minor revisions. Boundary distance metrics, such as 95th Percentile Hausdorff Distance (95HD), were found to be 2x more correlated to Mean Acceptability Rating (MAR) than volumetric overlap metrics (DICE). Conclusions: The introduction of SCARF, our auto-Segmentation Clinical Acceptability & Reproducibility Framework, represents a significant step forward in systematically assessing the performance of AI models for auto-segmentation in radiation therapy planning. By providing a comprehensive and reproducible framework, SCARF facilitates benchmarking and expert assessment of AI-driven auto-segmentation tools, addressing the need for transparency and reproducibility in this domain. The robust foundation laid by SCARF enables the progression towards the creation of usable AI tools in the field of radiation therapy. Through its emphasis on clinical acceptability and expert assessment, SCARF fosters the integration of AI models into clinical environments, paving the way for more randomised clinical trials to evaluate their real-world impact.

Ähnliche Arbeiten