Citation Verification Protocol (CVP)

Abstract

The Citation Verification Protocol (CVP) is a methodological framework designed to support researchers using AI systems by providing a structured process for verifying citation integrity, provenance consistency, and source traceability in AI-assisted scholarly workflows. CVP addresses two core failure modes commonly observed in AI-assisted research: Confirming that cited sources actually exist and are accessible Determining whether those sources substantively support the specific claims for which they are cited The protocol defines a clear, auditable workflow for citation existence verification, relevance verification, claim-level support verification, detection of common AI failure modes, and tiered verification rigor appropriate to publication risk. Key features of CVP: Public Verifiability Constraint (PVC): a mandatory exclusion gate requiring all citations to be freely accessible full-text sources (no paywalls, authentication, or partial access) Persistence and Archiving Requirement (PAR): capturing archival snapshots and content hashes to preserve auditability Evidence anchors: requiring specific page/section pointers and excerpts for claim support verification Explicit support ratings (FULL/PARTIAL/NONE/AMBIGUOUS) with clear disposition rules CVP is platform-agnostic by design, but requires AI systems with persistent, real-time web browsing access. Systems relying solely on training data, cached results, or simulated behavior cannot execute this protocol reliably. CVP explicitly does not replace scholarly responsibility. It requires researchers to personally read and evaluate source materials. CVP serves as a verification safeguard, helping detect non-existent citations, mischaracterized sources, and unsupported claims before publication. While originally developed within the Synthience Institute, CVP is published as a general-purpose research tool for any researcher employing AI systems in scholarly work across scientific, technical, policy, legal, and humanities domains. Applied example: CVP was applied to verify all citations in the RICO (Relationally-Induced Coherence Organization) technical report (10.5281/zenodo.18086834). The complete verification is documented in the RICO Citation Verification Report (10.5281/zenodo.18082749). The protocol verified full support for all externally sourced citations and independently flagged one internal citation where public access could not be confirmed at verification time, demonstrating that the protocol does not exempt the author's own work from scrutiny. v1.4 update: Corrected document ID from SF037 to SF0037 throughout; corrected affiliation to Synthience Institute; fixed section numbering in Implementation Procedure; corrected verifier identity field formatting; updated series label to Framework Series. Document ID: SF0037 Author: Thomas W. Gantz Affiliation: Synthience Institute License: CC-BY 4.0 Concept DOI (all versions): 10.5281/zenodo.18075624 For published work and Institute information: synthience.org

Ähnliche Arbeiten